DC Comics has a storied history in both print and film, with some movies achieving iconic status. However, not every film in the DC universe has lived up to expectations. Here’s a ranking of the three worst DC Comics movies, starting with those that were merely disappointing and culminating with the most infamous of them all.
3. Jonah Hex (2010)
Director: Jimmy Hayward
Jonah Hex is a peculiar entry in the DC movie lineup, largely because it attempted to blend the Western genre with superhero elements. The film, based on the DC Comics character Jonah Hex, stars Josh Brolin as the titular antihero, a Civil War soldier turned bounty hunter with supernatural abilities. Despite its intriguing premise, the film failed to make a significant impact, running a brief 82 minutes that felt even shorter due to its disjointed narrative.
The film was poorly received for several reasons:
Incoherent Plot: The story was widely criticized for being confusing and poorly executed, lacking the depth needed to engage viewers.
Underdeveloped Characters: The characters, including Megan Fox and Michael Fassbender, were not given much to work with, leaving their performances feeling flat.
Mixed Genre Execution: The combination of Western and supernatural elements did not resonate well, leaving audiences unsure of the film’s direction.
Jonah Hex may not be as notorious as some other entries on this list, but it is remembered as a missed opportunity in both superhero and Western genres.
2. Justice League (2017)
Director: Zack Snyder (with significant reshoots by Joss Whedon)
The 2017 version of Justice League was a highly anticipated film that ultimately disappointed many fans and critics. The film, which brought together iconic characters like Batman, Wonder Woman, and The Flash, was marred by behind-the-scenes turmoil. Zack Snyder’s vision was altered significantly due to personal circumstances, leading to Joss Whedon’s extensive reshoots and edits.
Key issues with the film included:
Incoherent Storytelling: The film felt rushed and disjointed, with plot points that seemed hastily assembled.
Visual and Tone Discrepancies: The tonal shifts between Snyder’s original vision and Whedon’s reshoots were jarring, leading to a visually inconsistent film.
Character Development: Important characters, such as Cyborg and The Flash, were underdeveloped, failing to capture the depth and complexity seen in other DC adaptations.
The release of Zack Snyder’s Justice League in 2021 provided a more coherent and satisfying version of the story, making the 2017 film seem even more out of place and less necessary in retrospect.
1. Green Lantern (2011)
Director: Martin Campbell
Green Lantern holds the unfortunate distinction of being one of the most critically panned superhero films in recent history. Starring Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan, a test pilot who becomes a member of the Green Lantern Corps, the film had high expectations but ultimately failed to deliver.
The main problems with Green Lantern were:
Lackluster Visuals: The film’s special effects, particularly the CGI used for the Green Lantern’s power constructs, were poorly executed and failed to impress.
Weak Storyline: The plot was criticized for being incoherent and unengaging, with a villain (Parallax) that was not well developed.
Character and Tone Issues: Ryan Reynolds, despite his charisma, could not elevate the film beyond its shortcomings. The overall tone was inconsistent, oscillating between serious and campy without finding a successful balance.
The failure of Green Lantern was particularly disappointing given the character’s potential and the pedigree of the filmmakers involved. It remains a significant low point in the DC filmography and a cautionary tale in superhero film adaptation.
These films represent some of the lowest points in DC’s cinematic history, each falling short of expectations for various reasons. While DC has certainly produced memorable and successful films, these entries serve as reminders of the challenges involved in bringing beloved characters to the big screen.
You Might Be Interested In:
